A Crash Course on EDI Industry Standards: ANSI x12 vs EDIFACT vs OFTP and more

Supply chains are complex. Globalisation has only compounded this reality. Although post-pandemic prediction of “slowbalisation” may reduce the steady 3.4% per annum growth in globalisation that we’ve seen since the 70s, the remote working transition could easily see this shift the other way.

EDI (Electronic Data Interchange) is a critical part of simplifying complex and global supply chain communication. However, to do that, it’s critical to understand the different EDI standards out there — and build an EDI solution that can flexibly accommodate a wide range of standards.

Modern approaches to EDI have simplified the adoption of this critical supply chain management capability — as the implementation of EDI needs to be seamless. This, in addition to the need to accommodate globalisation, are central reasons experts now predict the market is set to double in the next six years.

Here, we’re going to take a deep dive into those EDI industry standards by considering the most commonly used solutions, and how businesses can adapt to accommodate each of them.

Further reading: For further information on how to devise a supply chain strategy fit for 2021, check out our blog — How to Improve your Supply Chain Strategy Ready for 2021 

EDI Messaging Standards vs Communication Standards

Before we get into the specifics, we need to set out some definitions. When we talk about EDI standards and protocols, we refer not only to a variety of different standards but also to two distinct subsets, both of which ultimately need to work alongside each other for overall supply chain success. Those subsets are:

  • Communication standards (or protocols) which provide methods of data transference. This is the technical framework by which a message is communicated.
  • Messaging standards which involve how information is presented within the context of those protocols. This is the formatting that is used to standardise how those messages are received. 

Here, we’re going to break each down to size to find out what they stand to do for you, and how you can find your standard footing in even this global supply chain landscape. Although some standards are better suited for different tasks, what fundamentally defines an effective EDI system is its ability to accommodate a range of standards. Flexibility is the key to efficient supply chain management.

Communication Standards (Protocols)

Communication standards, or protocols, are key cogs in the EDI machine. They facilitate the exchange of information between data sources. Protocols can be either EDI-specific, repurposed or accountable for variations across supply chains. Businesses often need to accommodate more than one option. But, before that’s possible, you need to get to grips with the standards you’ll most likely come across, and what exactly each one has to offer.

  1. OFTP (Odette file transfer protocol)

OFTP is an EDI-specific protocol that was developed by ODETTE International, a European governing body for the automotive industry back in the 1980s. Our very own co-founder, Phillip Friend, helped to develop this all-important go-to protocol for big names like BMW, Ford, and Peugeot. A 2017 update that accommodates cloud-based communications, transmission restarts, and large file compressions, has delivered significant modernisation to OFTP. This contributed to its continued success across a number of industries including manufacturing, retail and finance.


  • File compression 
  • Built-in data integrity and delivery receipts
  • Second-level addressing (network and mailbox ID)
  • Interoperability


  • Complex standalone integrations
  • Requires registration with ODETTE organisation
  • Can be expensive if implemented in-house
  1. AS2 (Applicability Statement 2) 

The now obsolete, AS1, was developed back in the 90s and was the first ASX protocol to establish the signing, encryption, and MDN (message disposition notification) conventions. In 2002, these conventions became fundamental to upgraded, internet-based AS2. AS2 has become a prominent EDI protocol in the retail and consumer goods adopted by both Walmart and Amazon. Notably, its point-to-point connections which, essentially, create data transfer ‘envelopes,’ supported by AS2 certificates (and, interestingly, HTTP protocol) for increased data security at all times. 


  • Limitless data exchange
  • The ability to exchange all file formats
  • Transfer point-to-point or indirectly via VAN
  • No yearly or transaction fees


  • Single level addressing (network only)
  • Separate application integration
  • High maintenance efforts

OFTP1 & 2 are very similar to AS2 in reality — they both offer very strong encryption and reliability. However, OFTP 2 does in fact come out on top, technically, as it supports second-level addressing too (network and mailbox ID). Whereas AS2 relies on singular addressing, they use network only. 

Beyond this the main differences between the two are geography and industry. Broadly speaking OFTP is more prevalent in Europe, and AS2 is more utilised in the US. With regard to industry, the former is commonly used in the automotive sector, and the latter in the retail sector. 

  1. PEPPOL (Pan-European Public Procurement Online)

Cloud-based PEPPOL is both a communications and a messaging standard that was developed by the European Commission and a consortium of 17 partners back in 2008. Initially, its development stemmed from the goal to enable electronic B2B communications across government boards. Since its procurement by non-profit organisation OpenPEPPOL, back in 2012, it’s grown steadily in popularity — specifically across healthcare supply chains since its adoption within the NHS. PEPPOL focuses on providing interoperability and trading between connected parties using a 4-corner model that requires an access point (an AP), a PEPPOL network ID, a receiver, and a sender.


  • Standardised network connections
  • Compatibility with existing e-invoice platforms
  • Capabilities including electronic ordering/delivery notes


  • A relatively untested new protocol
  • PEPPOL network ID required
  • Risk of inefficient connection to the network
  1. FTP, SFTP, and HTTP

While not specifically developed to accommodate EDI, the protocols FTP, SFTP, and HTTP are commonly repurposed and used within an EDI context. This makes the common features within a supply chain environment — and they are all standards you need to consider within your EDI system. 

  • FTP (file transfer protocol): The first reliable file transfer protocol developed back in 1971. FTP is largely used for inner company file transfers — though added security for supply chain processes is possible when used within a VPN.
  • SFTP (Secure File Transfer Protocol): Originally developed by the Internet Engineering Task Force, in the late 90s, SFTP protocols run over the SSH protocol to encrypt data while it’s in transit, and decrypt it once it arrives at its destination. This ensures data security but, unfortunately, fails to offer any real data management.
  • HTTP (Hypertext Transfer Protocol): Established in 1991 as the underlying protocol of the World Wide Web, HTTP file transfers enable computer-to-computer connections requiring nothing more than the worldwide web. Security does leave a lot to be desired but, where ease is concerned, it’s certainly difficult to imagine anything better.

EDI messaging standards

While protocols concern how data is exchanged, messaging standards are all about the data itself. In most instances, messaging standards follow four key principles which are — 

  1. Syntax
  2. Codes
  3. Message designs
  4. Identification values

Given that there isn’t a standard format where messaging is concerned either, many businesses turn to a process called data mapping to translate each file into a data format that their systems can understand. The standard variations on the table include:

  1. UN/EDIFACT (the United Nations rules for Elec­tronic Data Interchange for Administration, Commerce and Transport) 

The most popular EDI file format outside of North America, and the only truly international set of standards, UN/EDIFACT was first developed for use by the United Nations in the 1980s. Now widely used, especially in Europe, EDIFACT facilitates multi-country and multi-industry exchanges. This has led to several industry-specific subsets, such as retail-based EANCOM. EDIFACT operates within a hierarchical structure. The pillars of which work together to create elements that are then normalised across EDIFACT structures to facilitate these famously easy, and incredibly popular, data interchanges. 

  1. ASNI x 12 (ASC X12) 

Initially developed by the ANSI subsidiary Accredited Standards Committee (ASC) in 1977, ASNI x12, commonly shortened to just X12, is a preferred standard for 300,000 businesses worldwide. Most commonly used in North America, X12 defines uniform segments and elements to describe file format information which is then used for a wide range of capabilities including invoices, purchase orders, and delivery notes. Unlike EDIFACT, which uses six-digit codes, X12 uses three-digit numbers for over 300 standards —each of which falls under a different industry-specific subset, including:

  • AIAG – Automotive Industry Action Group
  • EIDX – Electronics Industry Data Exchange Group (CompTIA)
  • HIPAA – Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act
  • And more

As touched on above, PEPPOL has been making waves as both a communications protocol and a messaging standard since its conception for use by government officials back in 2008. Embedded in eProcurement and eBusiness exchange systems, PEPPOL Business Interoperability Specifications ‘BIS’, are formal requirements to ensure pan-European data interoperability and have been widely used within the public sector, specifically within the NHS, since 2012. 

  1. VDA (Verband der Automobilindustrie)

Slightly more niche than other standards mentioned, VDA is a go-to within the German automobile industry, with the most recent iteration from 2017, VDA 6.3, providing a global EDIFACT message that aims to simplify previously convoluted global automotive trades. With a focus on support, future-proofing, and globalisation, VDA standards are now mandatory for tier 1 and tier 2 sellers in attempts to evaluate and improve controls across the board. 

  1. UN/GTDI TRADACOMS (Trading Data Communications Standard) 

An early EDI messaging standard used primarily in the UK retail sector, TRADACOMS was introduced in 1989 and was one of the precursors of EDIFACT. The standard was maintained and extended by the UK Article Numbering Association — now called GS1 UK. Technically, this standard has been obsolete since development ceased in 1995 in favour of GS1 EDI EANCOM. However, the lasting functionality of the solution has seen its retention by a large part of the UK retail sector. 

An effective EDI system needs standard flexibility

Standards and protocols are the bread and butter of EDI and always will be but, as you can see, each option brings both strengths and weaknesses to the table. Most problematic of all, however, are the incompatible standards that have long left computer systems entirely unable to understand each other, and thus complicated rather than simplified supply chain processes. 

This is something that trading partners need to overcome, and quickly if they’re to see any success on the global floor. Remember, you not only need to take into account your own EDI standards (and in-house expertise to manage your EDI system) but also the standards and expertise of every partner within your supply chain. Luckily, that goal is now easier than ever to achieve with EDI mapping that enables the facilitation of all standards and protocols, no matter the language barriers along the way. 

Here at Data Interchange, we understand the importance of this benefit well, which is why mapping capabilities are central to our modern EDI overhaul — EDI-as-a-service. EDI-as-a-Service harnesses both managed services and cloud-based tools to simplify the creation of a flexible EDI solution that overcomes the challenges of a legacy EDI approach. With these benefits on board, you can ensure that you’re talking the same language as even your overseas business partners, no matter their existing EDI experience, bringing the ease, and communications of EDI, even within modern business settings.

Further reading: If you want to learn more about how EDI-as-a-Service can transform commercial outcomes, check out our eBook — The Supply Chain Centered Business

Transform your approach to supply chain management

Talk to an Expert

    Epicor values your privacy. Website terms and conditions.


    Making the Move to Cloud-Based EDI Solutions

    EDI 940 T-Set: Structure, Benefits & Use Cases

    ANSI X12 EDI 865 T-Set: Structure, Benefits & Use Cases

    The VDA 4987 Message: Structure, Benefits & Use Cases

    ANSI X12 EDI 850 T-Set: Structure, Benefits & Use Cases

    The VDA 4938 Message: Structure, Benefits & Use Cases

    The EDIFACT DELJIT T-Set: Structure, Benefits & Use Cases

    The EDIFACT DELFOR T-Set: Structure, Benefits & Use Cases

    The VDA 4915 Message Explained

    The VDA 4905 Message Explained

    T-Sets | ANSI X12 810

    How to optimise your EDI and ERP system integration

    T-Sets | ANSI X12 997



    Exploring Cloud EDI Services in ERP: Architecture, Security, and Scalability

    VDA Explained: Message Standards and Transaction Sets

    ANSI X12 Explained: Message Standards and Transaction Sets

    EDIFACT Explained: Message Standards and Transaction Sets

    The Power of Web EDI for Global Supply Chains

    How to Get the Most Out of AS2

    How EDI Simplifies Transactions in the Manufacturing Sector

    Why Your Automotive Supply Chain Needs an OFTP2 Connection

    Digital Supply Chain Trends Impacting 2023 and Beyond

    How to Manage Global Supply Chain Complexities

    How to Overcome Supply Chain Risk

    What is the Future of Supply Chain Management in 2023?

    How to Improve your Supply Chain Strategy

    Why Scalable EDI is Integral to Rapid Business Growth

    How to Pick the Right EDI File Transfer Protocol

    An Introduction to OFTP2 (Odette File Transfer Protocol)

    What are the Costs of EDI Implementation?

    What is PEPPOL?

    A Guide to EDI Protocols

    EDI VAN Costs: Get the Right Solution for your Business

    How Much Does EDI Cost?

    How Do On-Premise EDI Solutions Work?

    Our Plan at Data Interchange to Change EDI and Supply Chain Management

    Integrating EDI with your ERP

    In-house vs Managed Service EDI

    What is an API Integration? And how does it affect EDI?

    Epicor Acquires EDI Provider Data Interchange

    6 Benefits of EDI in the Logistics Industry

    4 Challenges Facing the Logistics Industry and How to Overcome Them

    Top EDI Solution Providers in 2023

    Solving Supply Chain Problems in the Logistics Industry

    B2B EDI Integration Best Practices in 2023

    How to Choose The Right EDI Provider in 2022

    Supply Chain Analytics Trends in 2022

    Future-proof your business: Take Advantage of Market Growth

    Announcement: Andrew Filby becomes CEO of Data Interchange

    7 Advantages of EDI in The Automotive Industry

    Consumer Expectations cause Demand for Integrated Data

    How to Optimise Your Automotive Supply Chain Processes

    Post-Pandemic Supply Chain Challenges Increase the Pressure

    EDI Made Simple for the Automotive Industry

    Overcoming Supply Chain Visibility Issues in the Automotive Industry

    Complex Supply Chain Problems and Simple Solutions

    Supply Chain Flexibility: Why your customers need it

    5 Automotive Supply Chain Challenges Facing the Industry

    Supplier Performance Management Reimagined in 2023

    How to Unite Emerging Supply Chain Management Technology Trends

    Meet the Team: Marketing

    Supplier Management Best Practices after COVID-19

    The Future of EDI: Looking Beyond 2025

    The top three supply chain data exchange requirements

    The Advantages of EDI in E-Commerce: How to Gain a Competitive Advantage Online in 2021

    What is EDI Mapping?

    What is EDI: The History and Future of Electronic Data Interchange

    The Future of the Automotive Supply Chain

    Supplier Relationship Management: How to reduce risk and improve performance

    How EDI-as-a-Service Changes Supply Chain Best Practices in 2021

    Agile Supplier Onboarding: Supply Chain Security in Uncertain Times

    The impact of failed EDI on Supply Chain

    Cloud-Based EDI Solutions vs On-Premise

    Different Types of EDI Compared

    5 Most Common EDI Implementation Issues and How to Solve Them

    Are your EDI documents ready for the new EU/UK customs border?

    B2B Integration Challenges

    EDI vs API: Bridge the B2B connectivity gap

    Ten things to look for in an EDI Managed Service Provider

    World Mental Health Day 2020

    Logicalis & Data Interchange – partnering for success

    EDI – A data integration service critical to business success

    Joining forces with SnapLogic: bringing together market leading iPaaS and EDI solutions

    Joining Data Interchange: My lockdown experience

    Data Interchange announces strategic partnership with SmarterPay

    Access new trading partners quickly for COVID-19 support

    Keeping supply chains moving

    Our Web EDI solution gets a makeover

    Coronavirus: Our Business Continuity Plan

    With love from Data Interchange ♥

    A new decade, renewed ambition and the next generation

    Brexit and EDI

    Data Interchange transform their Support service for an improved customer experience

    Interview: An update on Data Interchange’s new CEO, Robert Steiner

    Data Interchange appoints Robert Steiner as new CEO

    MQ messages over ENX – Renault

    Five key questions for your EDI provider

    Data Interchange at the Odette Conference 2018

    How to select the right EDI provider

    Future proof your EDI and unleash growth

    EDI: the Supply chain performance enhancer

    Taking cost out of the chain

    Non-EDI users held up in the mail

    Over 41% of companies at risk without EDI

    ​Consolidating VAN providers

    Increase visibility and productivity of supply chain logistics with Data Interchange’s B2B integration solutions

    Data Interchange wins large business of the year award

    Data Interchange launch new Support Portal

    Data Interchange will be showcasing our EDI solution offerings and promoting the benefits of MMOG/LE

    Metaldyne receive special recognition from Ford for 11th consecutive year

    Top 5 reasons to switch to EDI Managed Services

    Data Interchange to power QAD Managed EDI On Demand